Send a Tweet
Exclusive to Bottom Up Mind:

A response to "Facilitating a Disruptive Emergence To Replace the Existing Elite System Running the Planet by Rob Kall"

By       Message Paul Krumm     Permalink
      (Page 1 of 2 pages)
Related Topic(s): ; ; , Add Tags Add to My Group(s)

View Ratings | Rate It Headlined to H3 3/9/15


Originally Published on OpEdNews

Sometimes old structures are replaced organically by new growth
(image by (image by Ian Sane))

Rob Kall's well documented position that disruptive emergence can be much more effective than revolution or system redesign makes a lot of sense.

What I got from it is the following: The crux of the problem is control by a banking elite. This elite needs to be replaced with local democratic institutions. So disruptive emergence needs to replace that set of hierarchical institutions with new ones that undermine the present powers.

I would propose that Rob's disruptive emergence needs to be combined with one of the concepts he replaces it with; system redesign. It would follow from his argument that any disruptive redesign needs to be based on the concepts of local control and democracy.

Where to start? I would propose that starting points exist in two areas. First are such diverse existing institutions as the WIR bank in Switzerland i, the Mondragon Cooperatives and their bank, Laboral Kutxa (begun in northern Spain and now active in 40 other countries, including the US where it has a cooperative agreement with the National Cooperative Bank of the US)ii, domestic Credit Unions iii, the Bank of North Dakota iv, and the alternative/community currency movement v. The reader may be reminded of others. The thing that unites all of these institutions is that their primary focus is local, and on service instead of profit.

Second is the theoretical work of money theorists, including Silvio Gesell vi, Irving Fisher vii, Edgar Cahn viii, Margrit Kennedy ix, Bernard Lietaer x, Tom Greco xi, and Robert Blain xii, who among many others, have all had an effect on my views.

A consideration of the work of money theoreticians and money institutions that are already moving in the direction of local democratic control, and how these present institutions can be moved to be more effective when joined in a web, along with new ones created as experiments, is a good place to start the effort to replace the present money power. A plethora of experiments would do the world good.

The conference proposed by Rob doesn't have to be a physical thing. Discussion, and action could equally well be coordinated and reported, for example, with articles on OpEdNews.

The following are a smattering of references. A Google or DuckDuckGo search will find much more.

i The WIR bank web site is only in German, French and Italian. The wikipedia description is at


Next Page  1  |  2


View Ratings | Rate It

I am a semi-retired self employed business owner who designs and builds instruments and machines. Obtained a BS in Sociology (with minors in Physics and Math) in the 1960's and became interested in studying the structural violence built into (more...)

Share on Google Plus Submit to Twitter Add this Page to Facebook! Share on LinkedIn Pin It! Add this Page to Fark! Submit to Reddit Submit to Stumble Upon

Go To Commenting

The views expressed in this article are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of this website or its editors.

Writers Guidelines


Top Content
in the Last 2 Days
(by Page Views)

Day For Indigenous Peoples-- Learn Connection Consciousness From Them by Rob Kall (10)

Bottom up and Top Down Religion; by Rob Kall (2)

Debra Sweet; Thoughts on Activism, Protest, Civil Resistance by Rob Kall (2)

Learned Helplessness in America; Bruce E. Levine Author of Get Up Stand Up; Uniting populists, energizing the defeated and battling the corporate elite by Rob Kall (2)

Awe is a Bottom-up Experience by Rob Kall (1)

Rabbi Waskow Will Potter - Avatar, Ecology, Ecoterrorism The Erosion of The First Amendment by Rob Kall (1)

Economist William Lazonick; Myths about Corporations that Feed the War on the Middle Class by Rob Kall (1)

Bill McKibben Ecology activist, organizer of the world's biggest Demonstration- by Rob Kall (1)

A response to "Facilitating a Disruptive Emergence To Replace the Existing Elite System Running the Planet by Rob Kall" by Paul Krumm (1)

Noam Chomsky by Rob Kall (1)

Deena Metzger-- Seeing through Indigenous Eyes, Weaving Community Dreams, Stories and Spirit by Rob Kall (1)

A Bottom-up Exercise in Understanding Top-Down, Hierarchy. Domination and Predators by Rob Kall (1)

Nicholas Carr, author, The Shallows; What The Internet is Doing to Our Brains by Rob Kall (1)

David Shankbone Grassroots, Photographer; most influential new media photojournalist in the world. by Rob Kall (1)

HBO Going Bottom-up-- That's A Good Thing For HBO and the Future of Media by Rob Kall (1)

Ari Berman; author Herding Donkeys by Rob Kall (1)

Thomas Frank on Mimesis, Capitalist Fundamentalism and Stealing Liberal Ideas by Rob Kall (1)

Naomi Wolf on teapartiers, transpartisanism, End of America Under Obama by Rob Kall (1)

Warren Buffett Quotation on Top Down Money by Rob Kall (1)

Facilitating a Disruptive Emergence To Replace the Existing Elite System Running the Planet by Rob Kall (1)

Mega Hit Producer Mike Medavoy on How Movies & Media Affect USA's Relationship with the World by Rob Kall (1)

Self Made Myth-- Mike Lapham-- co-author by Rob Kall (1)

Intvw w David Mathison Author, Be The Media-- the bible for tapping the power of the new media and old media . by Rob Kall (1)

Ellen Brown Interview Transcript Part II: Public Banking-- the Bottom Up Solution to a Lot of Economic Ills by Rob Kall (1)

Rory O'Connor-- The Future Of Media is Social by Rob Kall (1)

Go To Top 50 Most Popular